|
House GOP Not
Budging on Border
Leaders still committed to an enforcement-only plan and opposed to the
Senate's wider overhaul.
WASHINGTON (By Nicole Gaouette, LATimes) May 24, 2006 House Republican leaders
Tuesday resisted the latest White House effort to move beyond the
enforcement-only approach they have taken in rewriting immigration laws,
emerging from a meeting with President Bush emphasizing their continued
opposition to the broader approach the Senate is taking.
"The basic difference of opinion that we have seen on this issue between the
House and Senate and the White House is real, it is honest, and it was exhibited
at this meeting," House Majority Leader John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) said.
His comments came as the Senate worked toward a final vote expected Thursday
on its immigration bill. The remarks underscored that the divide between the two
chambers would be difficult for legislators to bridge.
The House passed a bill several months ago that focused solely on improving
border security and cracking down on the employment of illegal immigrants. The
Senate has crafted a measure that, along with heightened enforcement measures,
would establish a guest worker program and open a route to citizenship for most
of the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the U.S.
Despite the spotlight the congressional debate has thrown on the immigration
issue, the clash could mean that no measure will emerge for Bush to sign into
law.
Illustrating that growing concern, senators who back a broad overhaul said they
were worried that an informal House policy could thwart the push for a
compromise bill.
In the past, House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.) has blocked bills from
coming to the chamber's floor unless they were supported by a majority of
Republicans. He has reiterated that he plans to follow the so-called majority of
the majority guideline for immigration legislation.
As a result, a compromise that attracted enough backing from a combination of
Republicans and Democrats to pass the 435-member House would be kept from the
floor if it lacked the support of more than half of the chamber's 231 GOP
lawmakers.
"If Speaker Hastert insists on the 'majority of the majority,' [immigration
reform] is dead," Sen. Richard J. Durbin (D-Ill.) said Tuesday.
Like Boehner, Hastert gave little sign that he would be amenable to a final bill
that included the Senate's push for legalization provisions for illegal
immigrants.
When asked after the White House meeting if he viewed those provisions as a
"nonstarter," Hastert replied, "I think the first thing we need to do is secure
the borders."
Republican senators who support the broad approach to altering immigration
policy said failure to produce a final bill could hurt the party politically
especially in light of Bush's drive for such reforms.
"I don't want my own party to marginalize the president on an issue of great
national importance," Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) said.
"Much is at stake for our party. We have the White House, we have the Senate and
we have the House. If we can't solve this problem because it's politically too
hard for us, people are going to turn to another group to solve this problem."
Amid the discord, however, there was an indication that some House Republicans
were willing to explore finding common ground with the Senate.
Rep. Mike Pence (R-Ind.), leader of a House conservative faction, unveiled a
plan that would create a guest worker program that potentially could include
illegal immigrants currently in the U.S.
It would require them to briefly return to their home countries to be part of
the program, but it also would allow them to seek permanent legal resident
status a step to U.S. citizenship after six years.
Pence emphasized that, like many House Republicans, he viewed the legalization
provisions in the Senate bill as amnesty for illegal immigrants.
Senators, including many Republicans, who support their chamber's bill refer to
the provisions as "earned legalization." They argue it is not amnesty because to
gain citizenship illegal immigrants would be required to pay a fine and back
taxes, along with meeting other requirements.
But Pence, in a speech to a conservative think tank, said that allowing "12
million illegal aliens to stay in our country instead of leaving and coming back
legally is amnesty, no matter if fines or back taxes are paid, or how it is
otherwise dressed up or spun by its proponents."
As he detailed his plan, however, Pence said, "It is not logistically possible
to round up 12 million illegal aliens, put them on buses and conduct a mass
deportation."
It also is not realistic to think, he said, that some American businesses can
operate without those workers.
Under his proposal, illegal immigrants would be required to leave the country to
get a guest worker visa. They would be processed through placement centers, or
what he called "Ellis Island centers," run by private U.S. firms.
Pence said the process could be completed within a week, causing minimal
disruption to the immigrants and their employers. Applicants would have to go
through background checks. Visas for the program would be renewable three times,
for a total of six years, but only if applicants passed an English proficiency
test after the first two years.
"After the third term, they have to apply for permanent legal residence or
leave," said Matt Lloyd, a spokesman for Pence.
The bill would incorporate all the enforcement provisions in the House bill,
which includes construction of 700 miles of fencing along the U.S.-Mexico
border.
Lloyd said Pence had spoken about his proposal with Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner
Jr. (R-Wis.), author of the House bill, and the White House.
"They basically told us they're considering it, they haven't shut the door on
it, which we think is encouraging," Lloyd said.
But the plan met immediate resistance from Rep. Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.), leader
of House Republicans who oppose moves toward legalizing undocumented immigrants.
"Mike Pence is making the same mistakes that the president has using the straw
man of mass deportations and redefining amnesty to suit his interests," Tancredo
said.
He added that he was baffled by Pence's shift from an enforcement-only position.
Boehner described the Pence proposal as one of several efforts likely in the
weeks ahead aimed at finding a compromise between the Senate and House.
"I would suspect that this is one of many things that will be floated," Boehner
said. "I do not underestimate the difficulty in trying to come to some
agreement, but I am hopeful that we will be able to come to some agreement."
The Senate, in its debate Tuesday, continued efforts to reshape its bill in ways
that could make the measure more appealing to House members.
On a 58-40 vote, senators approved an amendment that would require employers to
check Social Security numbers and the immigration status of all new hires
through an electronic screening system administered by the federal government.
The measure also would double fines to $20,000 for employers who hired
illegal immigrants, and would send repeat offenders to jail.
California's Democratic Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer supported the
measure.
Also Tuesday, the Senate defeated an amendment offered by Feinstein that,
through the creation of what she termed an "orange card," would have allowed all
illegal immigrants now in the U.S. to gain legal status. The vote against it was
61 to 37.
Feinstein argued her plan would be simpler and less prone to fraud than the
bill's current provisions, under which illegal immigrants in the U.S. for fewer
than two years would be ineligible for legalization.
Several senators who voted against the amendment did not disagree with
Feinstein, but they said enlarging the bill's legalization provisions could lead
to its defeat.
"This legislation is on the edge of the ledge as it is," Sen. Arlen Specter
(R-Pa.) said.
The Senate debate has
mobilized groups opposed to legalizing illegal immigrants.
Black conservatives and activists formed an 11-member
coalition yesterday called Choose Black America, saying
competition for jobs and housing with immigrants have
worsened living and working conditions for blacks.
"We formed to oppose the
Senate bill," said Frank Morris, a former associate dean at
the University of Maryland. "The most vulnerable
constituents to immigration reform are African Americans,
especially African Americans with less education and
training."
The Choose Black America
coalition, whose news conference was sponsored by the
Federation for American Immigration Reform, called on
Congress to strengthen border security, boost enforcement
and deport illegal immigrants.
| |
|
 |
|
Jon Garrido Network Mall Sponsored Links
| |
|
|
Jon Garrido News will
be the largest video news website on the Internet for American
Hispanics and Latinos. National and local Hispanic news and
editorials will be available for viewing.
- |
|
| |
|
|
Act Arizona Arizona Universal Health Care
|
|
| |
|
|
Blue Dogs Home of the Blue Dogs of the Democratic Party
organizing across America.
|
|
| |
|
|
Hispanic is the number 1
ranked website in the United States
|
|
| |
|
|
Hispanic News is the
largest news website on the Internet for American Hispanics and
Latinos providing daily news, editorials, articles of interest,
plus home to the Hispanic News National Diabetes Center and the
Hispanic News National Election Center. Hispanic News is ranked
number 1 of 73,100,000 websites at Google.
- |
|
| |
|
|
Arizona News Premier
Arizona News website which includes Arizona 2006 Election Center
with focus on Phoenix.
- |
|
| |
|
|
The US Times is ranked number 1
of 39,848,811 national USA news websites at MSN. The U.S. Times
includes the National 2006 Election Center.
- |
|
| |
|
|
Latin America News is the
largest website on the Internet covering Mexico, the Caribbean,
Central and South America. Latin America News is the premier
business website of Latin America. Latin America News is ranked
number 1 of 4,097,970 websites at MSN.
- |
|
|
|
|
|
51 Plus
is the number
one ranked website for America's active Baby Boomers. 51 Plus is
number 1 of 243,000,000 websites at Google. |
|
Buy a link to your website
|
|
